Reviews for 03-06-05  


Justice League Elite #9
Publisher: DC Comics
Writer: Joe Kelley
Pencils: Doug Mahnke
Inks: Tom Nguyen
Nine issues down and three to go, the Elite are falling apart and the JLA seem to be coming in to clean up after them and shut them down. After losing one of their ranks last issue, the team is scattered and still trying to find out who the traitor is in their midst. Batgirl’s involvement is out in the open and Vera Black’s “secret” may be out, and while you are at it, mix in a little reality warping. I’ve enjoyed the entire run of this mini-series so far. While it isn’t what I would call great, it is entertaining enough to follow from month to month. I think this is something that will read better once collected. That seems to be the trend; pace the stories so when put together they read fine, alone, they kind of leave you a little flat. Mahnke and Nguyen do a great job as always with the art, I like the tonal change when Major Disaster gets a bit of the spotlight. It shows just how bad things have gotten for the team. I’m looking forward to see how this one wraps up.
-KEVIN-



Legion of Super-Heroes #3
Publisher: DC Comics
Writer: Mark Waid
Pencils: Barry Kitson
Finishes: Art Thibert
While the first two issues of the series were a solid enough start, I really liked how this issue turned out. It seems that the introductions are getting better and as more of them happen, the characterizations are getting stronger. This issue focuses on Triplicate Girl and her adjusting to life with the Legion. It seems her world was ravaged and she was left to try and rebuild it. Her powers to create duplicates of herself, extend well beyond the number three. She was able to build an army of duplicates that essentially re-built her world, but while there was several of her, she was essentially alone for quite some time. She discovered that the experiences she gained while split would be “absorbed” once all the duplicates were reassembled (See Peter David’s- Madrox series), but she desired more than the experience of her own world, so she decided to send a triad to join the team. This issue shows the effects of her trying to “date”, which had I been thinking, I would have seen it coming, but since I wasn’t paying too close attention, I didn’t see it coming. For people who thought the long history of the Legion would make the title too difficult to start reading, the creative team does a good job of starting from the ground floor. With enough small nods to the past, but nothing that saddles the new title, this would be a good time to join the Legion. .-KEVIN-



Batman #637
Publisher: DC Comics
Writer: Judd Winick
Pencils: Doug Mahnke
Inks: Tom Nguyen
I figured I would do this and the previous together so I could group the art teams accolades together and move on, so consider that done. Art Team-Thumbs up! Ok now on to the story. I like what Judd Winick is doing in this title, he’s illustrating the calculating side of Batman, the planning and implementing in situations, rather than the reacting. Batman and Nightwing are up against Amazo, the android with the powers of the seven original Justice League members; two non super-powers against, essentially, seven. I like the look into Nightwing’s thoughts regarding his former teacher and mentor, it shows that he still respects him and also understands why, when he was Robin, Batman treated him the way that he did. What I would like to see though, is a few stories that while they tie into the overall story line, they also give a new reader something to latch on to. There aren’t enough stories around that give the new comic book reader a chance to get a whole story in one shot. Batman is the perfect title to be doing something like that with. I consider it the “entry level” Batman, for those not reading the Batman Strikes book, and with it having the lowest price point of the Batman books (not the family, but Batman specific), it is a wonderful place to start drawing in new readers, but that is just my own opinion and not a strike against the work done by the team here. Collected, this would be a good entry level story.
-KEVIN-


X23 #3
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Writer: Craig Kyle
Pencils: Chris Yost
Inks: Billy Tan
I just wanted to take a moment to say that at first I was against this series, seing it as nothing more than another attempt to cash in on the “X” franchise and milk that cash cow. Now that I am three issues in, I am actually finding that I am enjoying the title. Much credit goes to the creative team for making that possible, since when it comes to the 350 X titles each month, I’m a little jaded. X23 has passed her first test by executing her sensei last issue, and now she has been sent out on several missions, doing what she has been trained for. She’s the second best at what she does, her genetic father is first. -KEVIN-


Fantastic Four #523
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Writer: Mark Waid
Pencils: Mark Wieringo
Inks: Karl Kesel
Only one issue left from this team, and I am sad about it. This run has been one of the most fun I can remember in a long time. Granted there were a couple of bumps in the road, but overall, this has been great stuff to read. Galactus, I mean, Galen, as he has been stripped of his cosmic powers by Reed and Quasar, is being introduced to what humanity is like. Sure it’s clichéd and somewhat predictable, but the outcome is still enjoyable. The threat of Galactus may be gone for the time being, but the team is left with other problems as Reed attempts to switch back Sue and Johnny’s powers, leaving the set up for their last issue as a team (the creators) as an interesting set up for their send off. I can’t tell you how much I’ve enjoyed the work this team has turned out from month to month, if you can, chase down the back issues or get the trades and find out why, for a time, it again became the world’s greatest comics magazine (I know a little over the top- but it was still good stuff). -KEVIN-

 
Al n' Ann's Collectibles

Store Hours:
Mon-Thurs
11:00am - 7:00pm
Friday
11:00am - 7:00pm
Saturday
10:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday
Closed

Location
3819 W. Main St.
McHenry,IL 60050

Phone
(815)344-9696

© Al n' Anns Collectibles All Rights Reserved